He is a brown animatronic bear with lighter brown coloring on his stomach, snout, and inner ears. He has black whisker spots, black eyebrows, brown eyelids, short eyelashes, blue eyes, and a black nose. As with the other toy animatronics, Toy Freddy has rosy red, blushed cheeks.

Toy Freddy's voice is generally described as having a moderately cartoonish quality with a somewhat heavy tone, sometimes with a British accent in early iterations. In some portrayals, he adopts the personality of a polite English gentleman, enjoying activities like reading and having tea. In other interpretations, he can be more mischievous or even jaded, with a tendency towards intelligent and sometimes profane comments. He is also voiced with a more good-natured tone in Five Nights at Freddy's AR: Special Delivery, suggesting he might see the player as a friend